Investors often get perplexed when trying to determine the 'proper value' of a stock. And understandably so, as it can get confusing at times. As always, it can be very insightful to hear what value investing guru Benjamin Graham has to say on the subject of calculating the proper value of a stock.
According to him, in the field of analysis of stocks, one cannot presume to lay down any specific rules that will help one arrive at the exact value of any given stock. This is because when looked at practically, there is no such thing as the 'exact value' of a stock in the first place. This is true as the bases of value itself are so constantly prone to changing that there cannot be any fixed formula as such that could claim to accurately determine the exact value of a stock at any point of time.
To Graham, the whole idea of basing the value of a stock upon the company's current earnings seemed inherently absurd, since it is a well known fact that the current earnings are constantly changing. And whether one should assign a P/E multiple of 10 or 15 or even 30 times to the earnings of the stock to arrive at its 'proper value' seems at its bottom, a matter of purely random choice.
To the investors who have been tracking the markets for quite some time now, the above argument might just look right. Most of the times, it appears as if there is no scientific basis to justify the valuations of a stock. It was Graham's observation that the stock market itself has no time for such scientific evaluation. Its nature is such that it must assign values to stocks first, and find its reasons afterwards. He compared the market's position to that of jury in a court case where a man has promised a woman that he will marry her and then changes his mind later for some or the other reason. In such a tricky case, there is no sound way for the jury to measure the values involved and yet, they must be measured somehow for the purpose of arriving at a verdict that just has to be reached.
This is the dilemma that leads to a situation where the prices of stocks are not carefully thought out values but are infact the result of a lot of different emotions. And hence Graham's classic quote: "The stock market is a voting machine rather than a weighing machine." The market, in effect, responds to actual data, not directly but first it impacts the thinking of the buyers and sellers and through this thinking, the prices. In other words, how much the price of a stock changes in reaction to a new information is not based on some exact calculation. The changes in price are infact arrived at through a filter of human emotions and compulsions.
At SAMPARK, we provide financial advice and distribute various investment products with the most efficient & widest range, customized specifically to your NEEDS..@ Whether you are keen on small investments or playing it big, We provide financial advice and distribute various investment/financial products with the most efficient & widest range, customized specifically to your NEEDs.
Thursday, September 10, 2009
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)
SAMPARK 75(193), G. T. ROAD RAMBANDHU TAKAW OPP-CHOWALAL SCHOOL ASANSOL-713303, (W.B),INDIA JALAN BHAWAN 52 N.S.ROAD...
A WINNER can show you d way to success.. But.. A LOOSER can make you.. Aware of all ways leading to failure..@
8 MILLIONS CHILDREN ARE NOT IN SCHOOL : THE POWER OF YOUR WORDS CAN HELP CHANGE THEIR LIVES .. JOIN THE MOVEMENT NOW
25. Kyoto University , Japan Kyoto University rated as 25th best university in World University Rankings 2009. Founded in 1897, Kyoto Univ...
Gold has always fascinated us Indians but do you know how prices of gold have varied in India. I happen to visit RBI website which pub...
Over the past month, several mutual fund investors would have received a mail from their fund house to update their Know-Your-Customer (K...
MY INTERACTION with one of my client on 12.12.2018 Sensex up today by 600 points* :scream: Manish : I am wondering Dr. AAA, why t...
One of my client get more than 6L as a benefit beside his SIP amount become double in the time span of about 8years. This event force me...
Dear All Today is the first day of the new Financial year and we all are free now as lockdown prevails due to Corona crisis, so let's...
Post a Comment